Please note: This post contains affiliate links. You can learn more about my product selection process here.
On May 1, Meryl Streep will grace us with Miranda Priestly’s presence once more in the sequel to the Devil Wears Prada. And while seemingly every brand on the planet has been trying to cash in on the franchise (I’ve seen everything from themed tweezers to an AMC popcorn bag), two clothing brands in particular are going head to head for the best Devil Wears Prada collection: Old Navy and Walmart’s Scoop.
Old Navy’s version, released on April 6 and ranging from $20 to $54, consists of T-shirts, sweatshirts and Andy Sachs-approved satchels. Walmart’s version, meanwhile, which opened up for pre-sale on April 10 and ranges from $16 to $54, will drop in full on April 20 under the Scoop umbrella.
A bit broader than the Old Navy collection, it houses everything from classic red heels like in the movie poster to jeans, skirts and power suits—and preorders are selling out fast.
So which collection do I think would get two nods from Miranda and which one would get the dreaded pursed lips?
My nods go to Old Navy, if only because it’s so on-the-nose. There’s an *actual* cerulean blue sweater, for pete’s sakes! One can’t help but appreciate the lengths Zac Posen & co. went to to not only honor the 2006 flick, but its beloved characters of Andy, Miranda and even Nigel, who gets his own bag. (And just like his character, it’s kind of the best.)
The Walmart Scoop collection, while far more wearable (are we really aspiring to wear the frumpy old cable-knit Miranda once ripped to shreds or is it just a cheeky nod?), doesn’t have nearly as strong of a viewpoint.
Sure, it’s more modern (I pulled the trigger on these barrel jeans) but which character can you see wearing, say, the lace-trimmed shorts or the peplum denim top? Miranda? Andy? Neither strike me as likely. *Maybe* Emily would try them, but in 2026, I’m not wholly convinced.
Based on what has been released thus far, this feels more like a collection of trendy things (I see you, fringe skirt) as opposed to a any sort of real tribute.
Below, the very best each collection has to offer.
Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Collection
1.Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Snug Crop Tee
Bearing one of two iconic lines from the movie in black or white, this crew neck tee is a must.
2. Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Oversized Hoodie
Did I just find the airport swag of my dreams? Yes, yes I did.
3. Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Nigel Crossbody Bag
This is my favorite piece from the Old Navy collection (I did call the East -West trend for 2026—just saying). It’s chic, it’s functional (hello, adjustable strap) and it’s the perfect, “more than the essentials, but not overwhelming” size.
4. Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Cerulean Cable-Knit Sweater
Andy’s infamous cerulean sweater gets its due in this cable-knit, “SoSoft” replica.
5. Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Andy Carryall
This workhorse of a bag is bound to be an office hero, and the chocolately faux suede will transition beautifully from summer to fall.
6. Old Navy x Devil Wears Prada Wide-Leg Jeans
The best part of these wide-leg jeans might just be the tiny printed stiletto on the hip pocket. They also come in regular, tall and petite (!).
Scoop x Devil Wears Prada Collection
7. Scoop x Devil Wears Prada Button-Down
Everyone needs a classic button-down, and this one features a fun little corset at the back. Ooh la la!
8. Scoop x Devil Wears Prada Fringe Skirt
The most eye-catching item in Scoop’s collection, this fringe maxi skirt is not only stunning, it’s (gasp!) machine washable.
9. Scoop x Devil Wears Prada Trench Coat
This faux silk trench has a silky texture I’m fairly certain Miranda would approve of.
10. Devil Wears Prada x Scoop Blazer and Pleated Trousers
This bold blazer set is giving Jacqueline, n’est-ce pas?
11. Scoop x Devil Wears Prada Slingback Heels
Put a pitchfork in it—these 3.6 inches slingbacks really cook.
12. Scoop x Devil Wears Prada Barrel Jeans
I love the medium wash of these barrel-leg jeans, though there’s also a snake print option if you’re feeling spicy.
Which brand do you think did it better? Let me know in the comments below !
Xo, Nicole
Leave a Reply